Audacity 4 Review: A Bold Rebuild With Growing Pains
The world's favorite free audio editor finally looks like it belongs in this decade – but a few old tools haven't made the move yet.
For close to two decades, Audacity has been the answer to "how do I cut this recording?" on millions of PCs. Podcasters, teachers, musicians recording demos, people digitizing old cassettes – sooner or later, everyone ends up in that gray window with the blue waveforms. Audacity 4, released in September and now at version 4.0.1, is the biggest shake-up in the program's history: a rebuilt interface, a new project format and a different way of thinking about clips and effects. We spent time with the current release to see whether the makeover is worth it, and who should jump in now.
First impressions and installation
Audacity is still free and open source under the GPL v3. On Windows you get a regular MSI installer for x64 PCs, a separate ARM64 installer for Windows 11 on Arm (without plugin support for now), and, since 4.0.1, portable 7z archives that run from any folder. The developers say the app is tested on Windows 10 and 11. If you need WMA, M4A or AC3 support, the optional FFmpeg library is offered as a separate download. Audacity is also available through MuseHub, Muse Group's free app store, but you don't need it – the direct download works fine on its own.
You don't need an account to edit audio. An audio.com account only comes into play if you want to save projects to the cloud or publish audio online. One thing to know before updating: Audacity 4 uses a new project format, .aup4. Your existing .aup3 projects open and get converted, but the conversion is one-way – the converted project can't be saved back in the old format, though the original file stays untouched. If you share projects with someone still on Audacity 3, keep that in mind.
Launch the program and the first surprise is a proper home screen. Under the Home tab you'll find "New & recent", "Cloud projects" and "Cloud audio files", with thumbnails of your recent projects and big "New" and "Open other..." buttons. It feels much more like a modern creative app than the old "here's an empty track, good luck" approach.
The new home screen lists recent and cloud projects before you open the editor.
A new interface built for today's screens
Open a project and the editor looks clean and current. The interface has been rebuilt on Qt with native high-DPI rendering, so it stays crisp on 4K laptops. Light, dark and high-contrast themes are included, plus accent and track colors and several clip styles. Toolbars and panels can be docked, floated, shown or hidden, and a workspace selector at the top switches between ready-made layouts such as Modern, Classic and Music. If you've used Audacity for years, Classic is a gentle bridge; newcomers can start with Modern, the default.
The top project toolbar gives you quick buttons for "Audio setup", "Share audio" and "Get effects", along with undo and redo. The familiar menus – File, Edit, Select, View, Record, Tracks, Generate, Effect, Analyze and more – are still there, so muscle memory isn't lost. Parameters now use rotary knobs: double-click one to reset it, or Shift-drag for fine control.
Some old habits have to go, though. The separate tool modes of Audacity 3 – Selection, Envelope, Draw and Multi-tool – are gone. Drawing kicks in automatically when you zoom in to sample level, and volume envelopes now live in an "Automation" layer inside clips. Sync-Lock has been replaced by ripple editing: the first time you delete something, Audacity asks how it should behave, and you can change your choice later in Preferences. Most keyboard shortcuts carried over, and 4.0.1 restored several missing ones, but expect a short relearning phase.
Clips, splits and non-destructive trimming
Clip handling is where Audacity 4 shines. Click a clip's header to select it, Shift-click to add more, and move, trim or time-stretch several clips at once. The top handle of a clip trims, the bottom handle stretches. Trimming is non-destructive, so if you cut too much, you simply drag the clip edge back out and the audio returns. There's a new Split tool (press S), plus split at silences and split to new track, and clips can be grouped and moved between mono and stereo tracks. Alignment guides and snapping make lining up a podcast intro or a drum loop much easier.
One caveat: "non-destructive" applies to clip edits and to realtime effects, not to everything. When you pick an effect from the Effect menu and click Apply, it still processes the selected audio directly – you can undo it, but it isn't a live layer.
Effects, recording and export
Realtime effects are now a first-class citizen. Each track has an "Effects" button (or press E) that opens a stack where you add, bypass or remove effects, and a "Master effects" section processes the whole mix. Built-in realtime effects are limited to Compressor, Limiter and Reverb for now, but the Compressor, Limiter, Reverb, Graphic EQ and Filter Curve windows have all been redesigned with clear knobs and live graphs. The classic toolbox is still there in the Effect menu, sorted into groups: Noise Reduction, Normalize, Loudness Normalization, Amplify, Click Removal, Noise Gate, Truncate Silence, Change Pitch, Paulstretch and many more. "Get effects" browses free and paid plugins and sounds from MuseHub.
The redesigned Compressor window uses knobs and a live transfer curve.
Recording got attention too: you can start recording anywhere on the timeline, Punch and Roll has been rebuilt, track headers show live meters, and Windows builds include ASIO support. The spectrogram view has been redesigned and renders faster. Exporting lives under File > Export audio, with MP3, WAV, FLAC, Ogg, Opus and more, and 4.0.1 brought back multi-file export per track or per labeled region – great for chopping an audiobook into chapters.
What's still missing
This is the part long-time users need to read. The developers list several features as planned for future releases rather than included in 4.0: Time Tracks, Note/MIDI tracks, the Mixer, the Macro Manager and scripting pipe, VAMP and LADSPA plugin hosting, and Play-at-speed. Users have also pointed out that Timer Record isn't available yet. VST3 plugins work, but if your workflow depends on macros, batch processing or a particular older plugin, test before you switch. Version 4.0.1 already fixed a long list of early issues, including project corruption after a failed save, problems converting .aup3 projects, trouble with non-ASCII file names and a launch failure with Windows Smart App Control. Screen-reader accessibility received fixes as well, and the release notes show it is still being worked on.
How it compares
WavePad from NCH covers basic editing and effects with a simple interface and is free for non-commercial use, but the full feature set requires a paid license. FL Studio is a full music production suite with sequencing, instruments and mixing – far more powerful for making music, but paid and overkill for editing a podcast. Nero WaveEditor handles straightforward recording and editing, but it can't match Audacity's effects toolbox or community. If you want to stay with the classic Audacity 3 workflow, the community fork Tenacity is another option. For free, general-purpose audio editing, Audacity remains the reference.
Pros and cons
Pros
- Free and open source, no account needed for local editing
- Modern, high-DPI interface with themes and workspaces
- Excellent clip editing with non-destructive trimming
- Realtime effect stacks per track and on the master
- Portable Windows build available since 4.0.1
Cons
- Several Audacity 3 features (macros, MIDI tracks, VAMP, Timer Record) not there yet
- One-way conversion to the new .aup4 format
- Workflow changes require relearning
- Prominent MuseHub and cloud integration won't suit everyone
Our verdict
Audacity 4 is the update the program needed: it looks and feels modern, clip editing is far more pleasant, and realtime effects bring it closer to a real production tool. For new users, podcasters and anyone doing everyday recording, cutting and cleanup, it's an easy recommendation – and still free. If you rely on macros, MIDI tracks, Timer Record or specific older plugins, though, keep Audacity 3 or Tenacity around for now and let a few more 4.x updates land before switching completely.
UpdateStar rating: 4/5
Get it on UpdateStar
- Audacity product page
- Download Audacity
- Audacity alternatives – including WavePad, FL Studio and Nero WaveEditor
- Related news: Audacity 4.0.1 released

